The Asymmetry of Truth: What Really Happened on Epstein Island?
Posted: Sun Nov 01, 2026 2:54 pm
https://www.skeptic.com/article/asymmet ... in-island/
Nearly everyone knows about Jeffrey Epstein. But what people disagree about are the exact details of what was regularly happening on Little Saint James in the Caribbean.
Certain facts are undisputed, but much is left to speculation. To fill in this information vacuum, people have constructed various scenarios. Some say that almost any high-class visitor who flew on Epstein’s plane must have known about, and even participated in, sex orgies with minors. This oftentimes includes public figures such as Noam Chomsky, Bill Clinton, and even the late Stephen Hawking. Others build upon the apparent Epstein-Israel connection, with this version of Epstein being a Mossad spy who blackmailed powerful figures. Many go beyond regular accusations, imagining that ghastly crimes such as zoophilia, cannibalism, even child sacrifice, were common on Little Saint James. And there are those, such as a colleague of mine, who, with fervor in their eyes and disgust in their voice, insist that the “Epstein class” engaged in literal demonic rituals and worshipped the Devil.
It’s possible that these scenarios are correct, but the catch is that all of them are most likely wrong.
Harvard cognitive scientist Steven Pinker has divided truth into two zones. The first is the reality zone, which focuses on the truth we can know directly and experientially, mostly through our own senses. With it, there is no negotiating. We can pretend all we like that our car runs on diesel, but if we pump diesel into a gas-powered vehicle, we’ll be leaving the gas station in a tow truck. We can lie to our parents about getting an A instead of an F, but once mom pops in to check with the teacher, we’ll be saying goodbye to our phone for a week. And if we fail to turn off the stove before heading off to work, we’re welcome to insist that truth is a relative social construct but the burned ruin waiting on our return will attest otherwise. In this zone, deviation from truth carries a price.